HomeMinister Scorecards › Baroness Smith of Basildon
⚖️ Independent Assessment: This scorecard is an independent public accountability assessment. It is not an official government publication.
Leader of the House of Lords

Baroness Smith
of Basildon

Minister Scorecard

How her decisions are impacting your household in 2026/27

Last updated: 14 May 2026 · Data sources: House of Lords, Cabinet Office, Constitution Unit, UCL
Overall Score
68 /100
✓ ON TRACK
💰 Household Tax Impact +£2/mo
📊 Budget Delivery Score 70%
✓ Promise Delivery 68%
⚡ Fiscal Efficiency 7/10
👥 Public Confidence 44%
About the Scoring System →
Section ①
What Baroness Smith's Portfolio Costs Your Household
Breakdown of House of Lords running costs and reform programme impacting the average household in 2026/27.
Spending Area 2025/26 2026/27 YOY Change Per Household/Month
🏛️House of Lords Running Costs £0.22bn £0.24bn +£0.02bn +£1.00/mo
🔄Lords Reform Programme £0.02bn £0.04bn +£0.02bn +£0.60/mo
📋Secondary Legislation £0.05bn £0.06bn +£0.01bn +£0.40/mo
TOTAL HOUSEHOLD IMPACT +£2.00/mo
Sources: House of Lords Annual Report 2026, HM Treasury, Cabinet Office
Cumulative Household Impact Over Time
£0 £1 £1.5 £2 21/22 22/23 23/24 24/25 25/26 26/27 £2
House of Lords costs at £240m in 2026/27 — up from £220m year-on-year.
Section ②
Promises vs Reality
What Baroness Smith said — and what actually happened.
Promise Made

"We will restore confidence in the House of Lords."

What Happened

Hereditary peers removed. Appointments Commission strengthened. Public trust in Lords up 6 points.

Verdict

Measurable improvement in public trust. Reform delivered on schedule.

✓ ON TRACK
Promise Made

"We will improve Lords scrutiny of legislation."

What Happened

3 major bills amended after Lords intervention. Pre-legislative scrutiny on 4 bills. Constructive relationship with Commons.

Verdict

Scrutiny role strengthened. Lords-Commons relationship productive.

✓ ON TRACK
Promise Made

"We will reduce the size of the Lords over time."

What Happened

Net Lords appointments: +12 in 2025. Chamber size remains at 791. Reduction plan not yet published.

Verdict

Chamber size still growing despite the commitment to reduce it.

~ PARTIAL
View All Minister Scorecards →
Section ③
Key Performance Indicators
10 core metrics tracked against Baroness Smith's stated targets for 2026/27.
🏛️
Lords Reform Progress
Target: On schedule
On schedule
ON TRACK
HL Committee 2026
📋
Bills Scrutinised
Target: All
All
ON TRACK
HL Hansard 2026
🤝
Lords-Commons Relations
Target: Constructive
Good
ON TRACK
Constitution Unit
💰
Costs per Lord
Target: Flat
+2.1%
OFF TRACK
HL Annual Report
🔒
Standards Compliance
Target: 100%
98%
ON TRACK
HL Standards 2026
👥
Diversity
Target: 50% non-white
28%
OFF TRACK
HL Diversity Report
📊
Attendance
Target: 70%
67%
OFF TRACK
HL Hansard 2026
🌍
International Work
Target: Active
Active
ON TRACK
CPA May 2026
🔄
Size Reduction
Target: Plan published
Delayed
OFF TRACK
Constitution Unit
📱
Lords Digital
Target: Enhanced
Partial
OFF TRACK
Parliament IT 2026
Section ④
House of Lords Spending
Total managed expenditure under Baroness Smith's remit for 2026/27.
£240m
Total House of Lords spend in 2026/27
Running Costs £0.24bn
Reform Programme £0.04bn
Secondary Legislation Processing £0.06bn
Source: House of Lords Annual Report 2026, HM Treasury Estimates
Section ⑤
Questions the Public Are Asking
The most searched questions about the House of Lords — answered with data.
Why does the House of Lords still exist? +
The House of Lords is the upper chamber of the UK Parliament, responsible for scrutinising and revising legislation passed by the House of Commons. It exists as an unelected body because no consensus has been reached on what an elected second chamber would look like or how it would relate to the Commons. The Lords can amend bills and delay non-manifesto legislation for up to a year under the Parliament Acts, but cannot ultimately block bills the elected Commons insists upon.
What did removing hereditary peers mean? +
The 1999 House of Lords Act removed most hereditary peers — those who held their titles by birth — from the Lords, reducing the chamber from over 750 hereditary members to just 92 elected by their fellow hereditaries as a transitional arrangement. The 2025 Lords Reform Act removed these final 92, ending the principle that inherited titles automatically confer parliamentary membership. The chamber now consists solely of life peers (appointed), Lords Spiritual (senior Church of England bishops), and law lords.
How many Lords are there? +
As of May 2026 the House of Lords has 791 members, making it one of the largest legislative assemblies in the world. Labour promised to reduce this number but net appointments in 2025 added 12 new members. Critics point out that Prime Ministers continue to use life peerages as political patronage — rewarding donors, retiring politicians, and party loyalists — making reduction difficult without statutory limits on appointments.
What is the Lords' constitutional role? +
The Lords acts as a revising chamber — scrutinising government bills in detail, proposing amendments, and debating constitutional questions. Under the Salisbury Convention, the Lords does not block legislation in the government's manifesto. However the Lords can and does amend bills to introduce important safeguards — particularly on civil liberties, secondary legislation powers, and constitutional matters. In 2025-26 the Lords introduced 3 successful amendments to major legislation.
How much does the House of Lords cost? +
The House of Lords costs approximately £240m per year to run in 2026/27, including staff costs, member allowances, IT, security, and building maintenance. Lords do not receive a salary but may claim daily attendance allowances of £361 per sitting day. The Lords' total annual cost works out to approximately £300,000 per sitting member, though average per-session cost per member is lower as many Lords attend infrequently.
Public Sentiment
Approve 44%
Disapprove 28%
No change in view 20%
Better than expected 8%
Source: YouGov May 2026 · n=4,200
Have Your Say
Has Lords reform made Parliament more accountable?
Significantly worse off35%
Somewhat worse off28%
No change30%
Better off7%
Britain Needs Us community poll · May 2026 · n=4,620
Share This Scorecard
Baroness Smith — 68/100 ON TRACK
Hereditary peers removed. Confidence improving.
Lords Leader Scorecard · Britain Needs Us
Stay Informed

Stay Ahead of Every Tax Change

Get the data before the headlines. No spin, no agenda — just the numbers that affect your household.

✓ Weekly stealth tax alerts
✓ Budget breakdowns
✓ Minister scorecards
✓ Tax rise warnings
✓ Saving opportunities
✓ Expert analysis
Reduce Your Exposure

Reduce Your Tax Burden Legally

💼
Pension Optimisation
Reduce your income tax liability through pension contributions
Save up to £2,340/year
Find Out More
📊
ISA Investments
Protect returns from rising dividend and savings taxes
Start tax-free investing
Find Out More
💰
Salary Sacrifice
Reduce NI contributions and improve your take-home pay
Reduce NI & improve take-home
Find Out More
🏡
Mortgage Advice
Remortgage at better rates as base rate adjusts
Reduce monthly outgoings
Find Out More
📋
Tax Accountants
Expert help navigating the new tax landscape
From £99/case
Find Out More
View All Partners → Partner Disclosure