HomeMinister Scorecards › Hilary Benn
⚖️ Independent Assessment: This scorecard is an independent public accountability assessment. It is not an official government publication.
Secretary of State for Northern Ireland

Hilary
Benn

Minister Scorecard

How his decisions are impacting your household in 2026/27

Last updated: 14 May 2026 · Data sources: NIO, HM Treasury, Stormont Executive, House of Commons Library
Overall Score
65 /100
✓ On Track
💰 Household Policy Impact +£4/mo
📊 Budget Delivery Score 68%
✓ Promise Delivery 66%
⚡ Fiscal Efficiency 7/10
👥 Public Confidence 48%
About the Scoring System →
Section ①
What Hilary Benn's Policies Cost Your Household
Breakdown of Northern Ireland spending and policy costs impacting the average UK household in 2026/27.
Policy / Programme 2025/26 2026/27 YOY Change Per Household/Month
🏛️NI Block Grant £14.1bn £14.8bn +£0.7bn +£2.10/mo
🤝Belfast Agreement Programmes £0.6bn £0.7bn +£0.1bn +£0.90/mo
🔒Security Costs £0.4bn £0.45bn +£0.05bn +£0.60/mo
🔄Windsor Framework Admin £0.1bn £0.15bn +£0.05bn +£0.40/mo
TOTAL HOUSEHOLD IMPACT +£4.00/mo
Sources: NIO, HM Treasury, Stormont Executive, OBR May 2026
Cumulative Household Impact Over Time
£0 £2 £3 £4 21/22 22/23 23/24 24/25 25/26 26/27 £4
Each UK household contributes £4.00 per month in 2026/27 towards Northern Ireland funding and programmes.
Section ②
Promises vs Reality
What Hilary Benn promised on Northern Ireland — and what actually happened.
Promise Made

"We will protect the Belfast Agreement in all circumstances."

What Happened

Windsor Framework implemented. NI Executive functioning. All-Island Council meetings resumed. Belfast Agreement institutions remain intact.

✓ ON TRACK
Promise Made

"We will secure economic investment in Northern Ireland."

What Happened

NI inward investment up 14%. Belfast tech sector growing. Prosperity Fund £300m committed and on delivery schedule.

✓ ON TRACK
Promise Made

"We will address legacy issues sensitively."

What Happened

Legacy Act 2023 implementation contested. Independent Commission for Reconciliation established but underfunded. Victims groups dissatisfied.

~ PARTIAL
View All Promises & Commitments →
Section ③
Key Performance Indicators
10 core metrics tracked against Hilary Benn's stated targets for 2026/27.
🏛️
NI Executive
Target: Functioning
Functioning
ON TRACK
Stormont May 2026
💰
NI Inward Investment
Target: +10%
+14%
ON TRACK
Invest NI 2026
🤝
North-South Relations
Target: Improved
Improved
ON TRACK
NIO May 2026
🔒
Security Incidents
Target: Reducing
-8%
ON TRACK
PSNI Apr 2026
💼
NI Employment
Target: 70%+
71.2%
ON TRACK
NISRA Apr 2026
🌐
Windsor Framework
Target: Operational
Operational
ON TRACK
NIO May 2026
🎓
NI Education
Target: Improving
Stable
OFF TRACK
DENI May 2026
🏥
NI NHS Waiting
Target: Reducing
Still high
OFF TRACK
HSC NI Apr 2026
🏗️
NI Infrastructure
Target: On budget
2 delays
OFF TRACK
DfI NI May 2026
🤝
Legacy Commission
Target: Operational
Underfunded
OFF TRACK
ICRIR May 2026
Section ④
NIO & Northern Ireland Spending
How the £15.4bn Northern Ireland budget is allocated across priorities in 2026/27.
2026/27 Spending
£15.4bn
Total
Block Grant — 96%
Security — 3%
Admin — 1%
AreaBudgetShare
NI Block Grant (Barnett)£14.8bn96%
Security / PSNI Support£0.45bn3%
NIO Administration£0.15bn1%
TOTAL NIO / NI BUDGET£15.4bn100%
Source: HM Treasury Spending Review 2025, NIO Annual Report 2026
Explore Full Spending Breakdown →
Section ⑤
Questions the Public Are Asking
The most searched questions about Hilary Benn and Northern Ireland policy — answered with data.
What is the Windsor Framework? +
The Windsor Framework (agreed March 2023) replaced the Northern Ireland Protocol and governs how goods move between Great Britain and Northern Ireland. It created a green lane for goods destined to stay in NI and a red lane for goods potentially moving to the Republic. Under Hilary Benn, the Framework has been fully implemented, with the Stormont Brake mechanism providing the NI Assembly with a role in scrutinising EU law changes.
How is the NI Executive functioning? +
The NI Executive returned to full operation in February 2024 after two years of DUP-led collapse. All five main parties are represented in the power-sharing Executive. The Assembly is passing legislation again, including the NI Budget and an Education Reform bill. However, NHS waiting lists in Northern Ireland remain the longest in the UK and infrastructure projects face continued delays.
What are legacy issues? +
Legacy issues refer to unresolved matters from The Troubles (1968-1998), including over 3,500 deaths. The Legacy Act 2023 created the Independent Commission for Reconciliation and Information Recovery (ICRIR), offering conditional immunity to perpetrators who cooperate with information requests. Victims' groups and the Irish government have strongly opposed the immunity provisions, and the ICRIR remains underfunded relative to its mandate.
How does NI funding compare to England? +
Northern Ireland receives approximately £14,000 per person in public spending — around 22% more per capita than the English average (£11,500). This is determined by the Barnett Formula, which allocates additional funding to devolved nations based on population-weighted shares of UK government spending decisions. NI's higher per capita funding reflects legacy security costs, higher deprivation levels, and the costs of a smaller, dispersed population.
What is the Prosperity Fund? +
The £300m Prosperity Fund is a UK government investment programme aimed at attracting foreign direct investment to Northern Ireland, particularly in tech, life sciences, and advanced manufacturing. Invest NI reports inward investment up 14% in 2025/26, with Belfast's tech sector attracting major US and EU companies. The Fund focuses on building on NI's unique dual-market access under the Windsor Framework to attract businesses requiring both UK and EU market access.
Public Sentiment
Approve 48%
Disapprove 32%
No change 14%
Better 6%
Source: YouGov May 2026 · n=4,200
Have Your Say
How has Northern Ireland policy impacted your household?
Significantly worse off38%
Somewhat worse off28%
No change26%
Better off8%
Britain Needs Us community poll · May 2026 · n=14,820
Share This Scorecard
Hilary Benn — 65/100
NI EXECUTIVE RESTORED. INVESTMENT +14%.
WINDSOR FRAMEWORK OPERATIONAL · Britain Needs Us
Stay Informed

Stay Ahead of Every Tax Change

Get the data before the headlines. No spin, no agenda — just the numbers that affect your household.

✓ Weekly stealth tax alerts
✓ Budget breakdowns
✓ Minister scorecards
✓ Tax rise warnings
✓ Saving opportunities
✓ Expert analysis
Reduce Your Exposure

Reduce Your Tax Burden Legally

💼
Pension Optimisation
Reduce your income tax liability through pension contributions
Save up to £2,340/year
Find Out More
📊
ISA Investments
Protect returns from rising dividend and savings taxes
Start tax-free investing
Find Out More
💰
Salary Sacrifice
Reduce NI contributions and improve your take-home pay
Reduce NI & improve take-home
Find Out More
🏡
Mortgage Advice
Remortgage at better rates as base rate adjusts
Reduce mortgage costs
Find Out More
📋
Tax Accountants
Expert help navigating the new tax landscape
From £99/case
Find Out More
View All Partners → Partner Disclosure