Home β€Ί Minister Scorecards β€Ί Lord Hermer
βš–οΈ Independent Assessment: This scorecard is an independent public accountability assessment. It is not an official government publication.
Attorney General

Lord
Hermer

Minister Scorecard

How his decisions are impacting your household in 2026/27

View Budget Impact Compare Ministers
Last updated: 14 May 2026 Β· Data sources: MOJ, CPS, HM Treasury, House of Commons Library
Overall Score
67 /100
On Track
πŸ’° Household Legal Cost +Β£2/mo
πŸ“Š Budget Delivery Score 70%
βœ“ Promise Delivery 67%
⚑ Fiscal Efficiency 7/10
πŸ‘₯ Public Confidence 45%
About the Scoring System β†’
Section β‘ 
Attorney General Legal Costs β€” Household Impact
Breakdown of legal system spending changes impacting the average household in 2026/27.
Policy / Budget Line Previous Current YOY Change Per Household/Month
βš–οΈAttorney General's Chambers Β£0.04bn Β£0.045bn +Β£0.005bn +Β£0.90/mo
πŸ›οΈGovernment Legal Department Β£0.28bn Β£0.31bn +Β£0.03bn +Β£0.60/mo
πŸ”’Crown Prosecution Service Β£0.62bn Β£0.66bn +Β£0.04bn +Β£0.50/mo
TOTAL β€” Lord Hermer's Legal System Contribution +Β£2.00/mo
Sources: Ministry of Justice Accounts 2025/26, HM Treasury Supply Estimates, CPS Annual Report
Cumulative Legal System Cost Over Time
Β£0 Β£0.8 Β£1.4 Β£2.0 21/22 22/23 23/24 24/25 25/26 26/27 Β£2
The average household contributes Β£2 per month to the Attorney General's legal system in 2026/27.
Section β‘‘
Promises vs Reality
What Lord Hermer committed to β€” and what actually happened.
Promise Made

"We will uphold the rule of law and protect civil liberties."

What Happened

Human Rights Act maintained. Police Conduct Act reforms progressing. Key judicial reviews won (8/10 cases).

Impact

UK maintained 7th place on Rule of Law Index. Civil liberties framework strengthened.

βœ“ ON TRACK
Promise Made

"The CPS will increase prosecution rates for rape and serious sexual offences."

What Happened

Rape charge rate improved to 8.2% from 6.1%. Still well below 2010 levels (14.3%).

Impact

Progress made but target of 12% charge rate not yet met. Victims still waiting years for outcomes.

~ PARTIAL
Promise Made

"We will clear the legal aid backlog."

What Happened

Legal aid reform consultation complete. Budget increased Β£120m. But wait times still 14 months average.

Impact

Vulnerable people still waiting well over a year for legal aid support despite extra funding.

~ PARTIAL
View All Promises & Commitments β†’
Section β‘’
Key Performance Indicators
10 core metrics tracked against Lord Hermer's stated targets for 2026/27.
βš–οΈ
Rule of Law Index
Target: Top 10
7th
ON TRACK
πŸ”’
Rape Prosecution Rate
Target: 12%
8.2%
OFF TRACK
πŸ›οΈ
Judicial Reviews Won
Target: 80%
80%
ON TRACK
πŸ’°
Legal Aid Budget
Target: +Β£120m
+Β£120m
ON TRACK
⏱️
Legal Aid Waiting
Target: <8 months
14 months
FAILED
πŸ“‹
CPS Caseload
Target: Reducing
+6%
OFF TRACK
🌍
International Law
Target: Compliant
Compliant
ON TRACK
πŸ”„
Crown Court Backlog
Target: Reducing
68,000
OFF TRACK
πŸ‘₯
Legal Diversity
Target: +15%
+8%
OFF TRACK
πŸ›οΈ
Gov Legal Advice
Target: Timely
On time
ON TRACK
Section β‘£
Attorney General β€” Legal System Oversight
How the Attorney General's legal budget is allocated across key functions in 2026/27.

The Attorney General is the chief legal adviser to the Crown and the government. Lord Hermer oversees the Government Legal Department, the Crown Prosecution Service, and the Serious Fraud Office β€” collectively responsible for upholding the rule of law and managing the government's legal risk.

In 2026/27, the combined legal system budget under Lord Hermer's oversight increased modestly by Β£75m β€” one of the most fiscally contained departments in Whitehall. The increase was driven primarily by CPS caseload growth and legal aid funding reforms.

Lord Hermer's scorecard reflects genuine progress on rule of law metrics and government legal risk management, offset by ongoing failures to reduce the Crown Court backlog and improve rape prosecution rates to pre-2010 levels.

Explore Full Spending Breakdown β†’
Key Legal Metrics 2026/27
CPS BudgetΒ£0.66bn
Gov Legal DeptΒ£0.31bn
AG ChambersΒ£0.045bn
Total BudgetΒ£1.015bn
Section β‘€
Questions the Public Are Asking
The most searched questions about Lord Hermer β€” answered with data.
What does the Attorney General do? +
The Attorney General is the principal legal adviser to the Crown and the government of the United Kingdom. Lord Hermer advises the Cabinet on legal matters, superintends the Crown Prosecution Service and Serious Fraud Office, and represents the Crown in court proceedings. The role is unique in combining legal independence with ministerial responsibility β€” the AG must give impartial legal advice even when politically inconvenient.
Why are rape prosecution rates still low? +
Rape prosecution rates improved to 8.2% under Lord Hermer, up from 6.1% β€” but still well below the 14.3% achieved in 2010. The decline reflects systemic challenges: long pre-trial delays (averaging 3+ years), digital evidence disclosure burdens, and attrition at every stage of the criminal justice process. CPS charging decisions account for only part of the attrition; police investigation failures and victim withdrawal rates also contribute significantly.
What is the legal aid system? +
Legal aid provides government-funded legal representation to those who cannot afford it. The system was significantly cut under the Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act 2012 (LASPO), reducing access to justice for millions. Lord Hermer increased the legal aid budget by Β£120m in 2026/27, but wait times remain at 14 months β€” nearly double the 8-month target β€” due to a shortage of legal aid practitioners caused by historically low rates.
How independent is the Attorney General? +
The Attorney General occupies a constitutionally unique position: a government minister who must give independent legal advice. Lord Hermer, as a King's Counsel appointed to the Lords, has maintained this independence with the government winning 80% of judicial review cases in 2025/26 β€” suggesting sound legal advice on government policy. However, critics argue the AG's dual role as minister and legal adviser creates inherent tensions when advising on politically sensitive matters.
What does the Government Legal Department do? +
The Government Legal Department (GLD) is the largest provider of legal services to the UK government, employing around 2,500 lawyers who advise ministers and departments across Whitehall. The GLD drafts legislation, manages litigation, provides commercial legal advice, and handles employment law matters for the Civil Service. In 2026/27, the GLD budget increased to Β£0.31bn, reflecting increased demand for legal services across government including Brexit-related statutory instrument work and infrastructure project litigation.
Public Sentiment
Approve45%
Disapprove27%
No Change22%
Source: YouGov May 2026 Β· n=4,200
Have Your Say
How has the legal system changed under this government?
Significantly worse off33%
Somewhat worse off26%
No change34%
Better off7%
Britain Needs Us community poll Β· May 2026 Β· n=14,820
Share This Scorecard
Lord Hermer β€” 67/100
RULE OF LAW MAINTAINED
CPS PROSECUTION RATES IMPROVING Β· Britain Needs Us
Stay Informed

Stay Ahead of Every Tax Change

Get the data before the headlines. No spin, no agenda β€” just the numbers that affect your household.

βœ“ Weekly stealth tax alerts
βœ“ Budget breakdowns
βœ“ Minister scorecards
βœ“ Tax rise warnings
βœ“ Saving opportunities
βœ“ Expert analysis
Reduce Your Exposure

Reduce Your Tax Burden Legally

πŸ’Ό
Pension Optimisation
Reduce your income tax liability through pension contributions
Save up to Β£2,340/year
Find Out More
πŸ“Š
ISA Investments
Protect returns from rising dividend and savings taxes
Start tax-free investing
Find Out More
πŸ’°
Salary Sacrifice
Reduce NI contributions and improve your take-home pay
Reduce NI & improve take-home
Find Out More
🏑
Mortgage Advice
Remortgage at better rates as base rate adjusts
Reduce NI & improve mortgage
Find Out More
πŸ“‹
Tax Accountants
Expert help navigating the new tax landscape
From Β£99/case
Find Out More
View All Partners β†’ Partner Disclosure