The most searched questions about Shabana Mahmood — answered with data.
Why is the asylum backlog still growing?
+
The asylum backlog has nearly doubled since Labour took office, reaching 98,000 cases in April 2026 (Home Office statistics). Average case processing time is now 18 months, up from 14 months in mid-2024. The Asylum and Immigration Tribunal has a concurrent backlog of 21,000 appeals. Staffing increases at UK Visas and Immigration have not kept pace with application volumes, which rose 22% in 2025/26. The Government's "New Plan for Immigration" has yet to pass all its legislative stages.
Why are knife crime rates rising?
+
Knife crime offences recorded by police rose 12% year-on-year in the year to March 2026 (ONS). Police recruitment has stalled: the target of 5,000 additional officers has delivered only 1,800 so far. HMICFRS inspection reports highlight that many forces are still running below establishment numbers. The Violence Reduction Units, expanded by Labour, have shown mixed results. Critics argue the policing precept — adding £4.80/month to household bills — has not translated into visible community policing or crime prevention outcomes.
How much do asylum hotels cost per household per year?
+
With 42,000 asylum seekers housed in hotels at an average cost of £150/night per person, annual hotel costs total approximately £2.3bn. This equates to roughly £82 per UK household per year — or £6.83/month. The Government has not released a full breakdown of its hotel procurement contracts despite Freedom of Information requests from multiple media organisations. The Home Affairs Select Committee has called for an immediate independent audit of hotel accommodation costs and alternative options.
Why haven't police recruitment targets been met?
+
Police recruitment faces a structural challenge: high attrition rates (officers leaving) are partially offsetting new recruits. Starting salaries for police constables, while improved, remain uncompetitive with private sector roles in many force areas. Forces in London, the South East, and major cities report particular difficulty meeting establishment numbers. The College of Policing reports that training capacity has been a bottleneck. Despite the policing precept adding over £1.6bn to council tax bills nationally, only 1,800 of the targeted 5,000 new officers have been recruited by May 2026.
What has the Illegal Migration Act actually achieved?
+
Labour inherited the Illegal Migration Act from the previous government and chose not to repeal it, instead pursuing operational changes. Key metrics have deteriorated: small boat crossings rose 18% in the year to April 2026. Only 890 deportation flights took place against a target of 2,400. The Rwanda partnership was formally ended, with no replacement deterrent announced. The Home Office has begun developing a new returns and enforcement strategy, expected to be published in late 2026, but critics argue the gap between promise and delivery has significantly undermined public confidence in immigration control.